Drew and Alyssa matched on Tinder back in February 2023. Alyssa was busy enjoying a girls’ weekend, so she didn’t reply to Drew’s first message for a few days. But hey—good things come to those who wait!

When she finally did respond, Alyssa was feeling under the weather. Drew suggested a low-key meet-up, bringing ice cream for her and dog treats for Sophie. Before meeting, they jokingly made each other swear they weren’t murderers—a modern-day trust exercise.

What started as a cozy, slightly messy hangout quickly turned into hours of laughter and connection. And now? They’re headed to the altar, proving that sometimes the best love stories start with patience, ice cream, and a good sense of humor.